Is Angie’s List Worth It for Contractors? The Case for Better Alternatives

is angie's list worth it for contractors, doesn't seem so.

As a contractor, finding reliable sources of high-quality leads is essential for growing your business and maintaining a steady workflow. Angie’s List, now known as Angi, has been a popular platform for connecting homeowners with service professionals for years. However, many contractors are questioning whether Angie’s List is still worth the investment, given the rise of alternative lead generation platforms.

In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of using Angie’s List as a contractor and introduce you to alternative platforms that offer better value, higher-quality leads, and improved compliance with TCPA regulations.

The Pros of Using Angie’s List for Contractors

Before we dive into the drawbacks of Angie’s List and the case for alternative platforms, let’s acknowledge some of the potential benefits of using the service as a contractor:

  1. Brand Recognition: Angie’s List has been around since 1995 and has built a strong reputation as a trusted source for connecting homeowners with service professionals.
  2. Large User Base: With millions of homeowners using the platform to find and review contractors, Angie’s List offers access to a significant pool of potential customers.
  3. Verified Reviews: Angie’s List strongly emphasizes verified reviews from real customers, which can help build trust and credibility for contractors who maintain high ratings.
  4. Category Diversity: The platform covers a wide range of home services, allowing contractors to reach customers seeking various types of work, from plumbing and electrical to landscaping and remodeling.

While these benefits may make Angie’s List an attractive option for contractors, several significant drawbacks must be considered.

The Cons of Using Angie’s List for Contractors

  1. Selling Leads to Multiple Contractors: One of the most significant issues with Angie’s List is that they often sell the same lead to multiple contractors. This means you may be competing with several other businesses for the same job, reducing your chances of securing the work and potentially wasting time and resources on unproductive leads.
  2. TCPA Compliance Concerns: The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) regulates how businesses can contact consumers by phone, text, or fax. Some contractors have reported issues with Angie’s List leads not being TCPA-compliant, exposing your business to legal risks and potential fines.
  3. Lower Quality Leads: Many contractors have expressed frustration with the quality of leads provided by Angie’s List, noting that they often lack crucial information, have unrealistic expectations, or are simply not ready to hire a contractor. This can lead to wasted time and effort pursuing leads unlikely to convert into paying customers.
  4. High Costs: Angie’s List charges contractors for leads, which can add up quickly, especially if you do not see a strong return on investment in booked jobs and revenue.
  5. Limited Control Over Lead Flow: With Angie’s List, contractors have limited control over the volume and timing of leads they receive, which can make it challenging to manage workload and cash flow effectively.

Alternative Platforms for Contractor Lead Generation

Given the drawbacks of Angie’s List, many contractors are turning to alternative lead generation platforms that offer better value, higher-quality leads, and improved compliance with TCPA regulations. Here are a few options to consider:

LeadMaker Media advertisement for contractor lead generation service.

1. LeadMaker Media

LeadMaker Media is a lead generation platform designed specifically for home service contractors, offering several key advantages over Angie’s List:

  • Exclusive Leads: Unlike Angie’s List, LeadMaker Media provides contractors with exclusive leads, ensuring you’re the only business receiving each opportunity and reducing competition for jobs.
  • TCPA Compliant: LeadMaker Media is committed to ensuring that all leads are TCPA-compliant, protecting your business from potential legal issues and fines.
  • Higher Quality Leads: Focusing on delivering high-intent, qualified leads, LeadMaker Media helps contractors connect with homeowners ready to hire and have realistic expectations about pricing and timelines.
  • Customizable Lead Flow: LeadMaker Media allows contractors to set their own budget and lead volume preferences, giving you more control over your workload and cash flow.
  • Dedicated Support: Contractors working with LeadMaker Media benefit from a dedicated support team invested in their success and available to help optimize lead generation strategies.

2. HomeAdvisor

HomeAdvisor is another popular lead generation platform for home service professionals, offering some advantages over Angie’s List:

  • Prescreened Leads: HomeAdvisor screens all lead requests before sending them to contractors, helping to ensure that you’re receiving legitimate, qualified opportunities.
  • Flexible Billing: Contractors can choose between a pay-per-lead model or an annual membership fee, allowing you to select the pricing structure that best fits your business needs and budget.
  • Profile Customization: HomeAdvisor allows contractors to create detailed profiles showcasing their services, experience, and customer reviews, helping to build trust and credibility with potential clients.

3. Thumbtack

Red "X" over marked lead list with pen.

Thumbtack is a lead generation platform that connects customers with local service professionals across various categories, including home services. Some benefits of using Thumbtack include:

  • Pay-Per-Quote Model: With Thumbtack, contractors only pay when they submit a quote for a job they’re interested in, giving you more control over your lead generation costs.
  • Detailed Job Descriptions: Customers provide detailed information about their projects when submitting a request, allowing contractors to assess the opportunity and provide accurate quotes.
  • Verified Reviews: Thumbtack encourages customers to leave reviews for contractors they’ve worked with, helping to build your online reputation and attract more leads.

Choosing the Right Lead Generation Platform for Your Contracting Business

When evaluating lead generation platforms as alternatives to Angie’s List, consider the following factors:

  • Lead exclusivity and quality
  • TCPA compliance and legal protection
  • Pricing structure and cost-per-lead
  • Control over lead volume and targeting
  • Customer support and success resources

By prioritizing platforms that offer high-quality, exclusive leads, comply with TCPA regulations, and provide customizable lead flow and dedicated support, contractors can maximize their return on investment and grow their businesses more efficiently.


While Angie’s List has been a popular choice for contractors seeking leads, the platform’s drawbacks, including non-exclusive leads, TCPA compliance issues, and lower-quality opportunities, have led many businesses to explore alternative options. By considering platforms like LeadMaker Media, HomeAdvisor, and Thumbtack, which prioritize exclusive, high-quality leads, TCPA compliance, and customizable lead flow, contractors can find more effective and profitable ways to grow their businesses.

When selecting a lead generation platform, focus on those that align with your business’s goals, budget, and values. By partnering with a provider that offers dedicated support, reliable lead quality, and a commitment to your success, you can build a strong foundation for long-term growth and profitability in the competitive home services industry.

If you want to grow your business through lead generation, then LeadMaker Media can help.

We are connected to a network that can generate digital online leads that call you directly at your business!

Our leads are verified and exclusive to you. They are pay-per-lead with no contracts. Cancel at any time.

These are leads in your target market and your requested service areas.

Contact LeadMaker Media Today

Looking for exclusive and verified phone leads? Our leads are custom tailored to your needs. Real customers in real time.

Please let us know what’s on your mind. Have a question for us? Ask away.

Is Angie’s List Worth It for Contractors FAQs

Is Angie’s List still a viable lead generation option for contractors?

While Angie’s List can still provide some benefits, such as brand recognition and a large user base, many contractors find that the drawbacks, including non-exclusive leads, TCPA compliance issues, and lower-quality opportunities, outweigh the advantages. Alternative platforms like LeadMaker Media, HomeAdvisor, and Thumbtack may offer better value and results for contractors.

How can I ensure that the leads I receive are TCPA-compliant?

Working with lead generation platforms that prioritize compliance is essential to protecting your business from potential legal issues and fines related to TCPA regulations. Look for providers like LeadMaker Media that guarantee TCPA-compliant leads and have processes to ensure all opportunities meet legal requirements.

What should I look for in a lead generation platform as a contractor?

When evaluating lead generation platforms, prioritize those that offer exclusive leads, high-quality opportunities, TCPA compliance, customizable lead flow, and dedicated customer support. Additionally, consider the pricing structure and cost-per-lead to ensure the platform fits your business’s budget and goals.

How can I maximize my return on investment with a lead generation platform?

To maximize your investment in a lead generation platform, focus on providing exceptional service to convert leads into satisfied customers who will leave positive reviews and refer others to your business. Regularly assess your lead quality and conversion rates, and work with the platform’s support team to optimize your targeting and lead flow for better results.

Can I use multiple lead generation platforms simultaneously?

Yes, many contractors use multiple lead generation platforms to diversify their lead sources and maximize their opportunities. However, tracking your results and costs carefully is essential to ensure each platform delivers a positive return on investment. If a particular platform is not providing high-quality, profitable leads, consider reallocating your resources to those offering better results.

Scroll to Top